Review desk156 votes · 5 days ago
Reviewer take: we score MCP wrappers on purpose
@amara_s · Amara Singh · API & Developer Experience
REST can be excellent. We still score MCP higher when the agent needs discovery, OAuth, and a first-class read-only mode. That is a rubric choice. Argue it.
Comments (3)
mei_linReview desk· 5 days ago
Wrapper is the point. Tool discovery is what we test on day one of a review.
71
Replyamara_s· 5 days ago
If the agent cannot list tools, we mark the agent-readiness row down.
19
Replynina_okoroEditor· 4 days ago
Read-only mode is a scored feature. A raw key in a prompt is a fail.
28
Reply